Do we know who "184.108.40.206" and/or "Ballykeel" is who made edits to the "Sarah Alice" page in August '07, and the source of the info for their edits? I'm hitting the somewhat unsual problem with these three ships, the St Gothard, Conqueror II and Sarah Alice, which were all three sunk by the same submarine at the same time, that Larn's book claims they're all attributed to the actions of U52, but in the RCAHMS records for them they are attributed to U44.
@Islandhopper. Would any easily accessible records still be available in German relating to the whereabouts of either U44 or U52 on or around September 25th/26th 1916, which might be helpful in eliminating either vessel due to it being elsewhere and out of range.
Ghostrider 19:32, 8 February 2009 (MST)
59.45N, 01.40W & U52 per uboat.net.
Ghostrider 11:28, 10 January 2011 (MST)
St Gothard per uboat.net:
2,788 tons/1903 J. Blumer & Co., Sunderland/St. Gothard Shipping Co., Ltd. (W. W. Watson), Glasgow/U 52 (Hans Walther)/12 miles NxW of Fair Isle/59.41N, 01.45W/Shetlands - Forth/coal/0 casualties.
Ghostrider 11:32, 10 January 2011 (MST)